UnTax – Taxing Away Climate Change
We have tried everything: political decisions, climate change conferences (COP 26 due in 2021), emissions rights trading, or taxing carbon, yet carbon emissions keep rising year after year, and carbon concentration in the earth’s atmosphere are ticking up like clockwork. Nothing suggests that this will change in the near future, despite all the renewed promises by governments worldwide.
Yet the reason for this inertia is simple: the price we pay for fossil fuels, and most other non-renewable resources, is far too low, because we don’t pay for their creation which took hundreds of millions of years, but only for their extraction. And most natural resources are not or only lightly taxed.
At the same time, labor is by far the highest-taxed element in most countries, which discourages employment and forces automation into every part of the economy.
This mix-up, a by-product of the industrial revolution, leads to pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, waste production and the unnecessary use of automation, which damages our ecosystems and at the same time deprives future generations of their right to access those scarce resources.
By going back to taxes on the use of non-renewable resources, the UnTax project wants to set this right, fixing almost everything that is broken about our way we deal with natural resources.
How UnTaxing works
Remove all labor-related taxes
Make working and fixing things more attractive by setting all personal taxes and social security payments to zero
Tax non-renewable resources
The tax is set so the price of non-renewable resources is higher than the full cost of recycled/renewable inputs
Tax imports to match domestic outputs
Imports from countries with traditional tax systems are surtaxed to match local products and services
Makes employment more attractive
By eliminating taxes and social security payments, labor becomes more attractive and higher minimum wages become possible
Encourages a circular economy
High prices for non-renewable resources encourage R&D that favors products that can be easily repaired and recycled, and supports re- and upcycling
Fights waste, pollution and climate change
Reduces use of non-renewable resources, including fossil fuels. leaving more for our children and cutting waste and carbon emissions dramatically
UnTax is a joint initiative of the Institute for the Study of Energy and Our Future (ISEOF) and the Institute for Integrated Economic Research (IIER). We are currently building a much larger coalition of partners to support this effort, with the objective to have legislation-ready proposals ready by late 2021 or early 2022.
Gordon Schücker, MSc
Gordon Schücker holds a Masters degree in Mathematics, summa cum laude, from the University of Göttingen and a degree in Political Economics. He dedicates his time understanding multiple complex systems through the energy and finance prism. His focus began in the study of the global shadow banking system and later shifted to the energy and ecology nexus. His interests also expand into Geopolitics and Economics.
Gordon is a member of Economists for Future DE and passionate about improving education in systems thinking.
Nate Hagens, PhD
Nate Hagens is a member of the Board of Directors of the Systemic Economic Response Initiative. He holds a PhD in Natural Resources from the University of Vermont and a Masters Degree in Finance with Honors from the University of Chicago. Previously he was President of Sanctuary Asset Management and a Vice President at the investment firms Salomon Brothers and Lehman Brothers. He served on the Board of Post Carbon Institute (PCI) and the Institute for the Study of Energy and Our Future (ISEOF), parent of The Oil Drum, one of the most popular websites for analysis and discussion of global energy issues, currently engaged with energy, systems literacy and education.
Hannes Kunz, PhD
Hannes Kunz holds Masters degrees in Law and Economics from the University of Zurich, and a PhD in Economics from St. Gallen University in Switzerland. Before founding IIER, he worked as a senior executive in a number of industries and as a partner in international management consulting companies with assignments in Europe, the Americas and in Asia. His research focus lies on finance, debt and on energy delivery systems.
Hannes has served on the board of various non-profit organizations, and is also a board member of the Institute for the Study of Energy and Our Future (ISEOF).
Frequently Asked Questions
What does UnTax differentiate from other initiatives or a Carbon Tax?
What is the motivation behind your initiative?
When looking at the success of all initiatives to curb climate change, and the unabated use of natural resources, we consider it relevant to come up with ideas that have the potential to finally make a difference. Of all ideas we have evaluated, using a “market approach” that simply rectifies a problem of non-renewable resource use seems most promising.
What does "UnTaxing" mean for social security?
The UnTax approach would not change social security benefits to individuals, but it would fundamentally change how they would be funded. Money for social security would no longer come from deductions on wages, but now from taxes levied on non-renewable resources.
Doesn't taxing resource use go against the idea of "market"?
From our perspective, quite the contrary is true. The fact that we are unearthing non-renewable resources (fossil fuels, ores, freshwater) at a speed that cannot continue forever is a good indicator of an incorrect signal to markets. Not demanding that we pay for non-renewable resources a price that includes their “regeneration” is as if a company would sell all their products on a yard sale not covering their true cost. They would soon go out of business. And that’s exactly what we are risking with planet Earth, damaging the prospects of future generations.
Does your ideas translate to "more taxes"?
The idea behind UnTax is to make a switch from taxing labor and profits to taxing non-renewable resources neutral, not increasing the overall tax burden for people and companies, just a shift.
Do you have any political affiliation?
UnTax is strictly non-political and neutral, we are driven by science and analysis, and our main objective is to contribute to solving important problems of our world.
Who funds your work?
Our work is funded by donations from individuals and from institutional grants. None of our funders have any say on the direction or content of our work, and we do not accept grants that include such instructions.